Welcome to the J. Sidna Allen House, a unique piece of Virginia’s history nestled in the picturesque hills of Carroll County. Built in 1911, this house stands as a testament to the Queen Anne architectural style, characterized by its complex roofline, hexagonal tower, and intricate ornamental wood trim. But beyond its architectural beauty, the Allen House is a silent witness to one of the most notorious events in Virginia’s history—the Hillsville Massacre of 1912.
J. Sidna Allen, alongside his wife Bettie, envisioned this home as a symbol of their prosperity and status. However, their time here was short-lived. Just a year after moving in, the Hillsville courthouse shooting occurred, a tragic event that claimed the lives of a judge, prosecutor, and three others. Sidna Allen, implicated in this courtroom drama alongside his brother Floyd Allen, was sentenced to life imprisonment. The house, commandeered by the state, remained a haunting reminder of the Allen family’s fall from grace.
The Allen House is more than just bricks and mortar; it’s a cornerstone of local folklore. The Carroll County Historical Society, recognizing its historical significance, has embarked on a mission to restore this once-magnificent residence. Though currently closed to the public, efforts are underway to return the home to its former glory, preserving its legacy for future generations.
The stories embedded in the walls of the J. Sidna Allen House are not just about a family or a town but about a community’s struggle with justice, legacy, and memory. As you reflect on the events that unfolded here, consider the broader implications of the Hillsville Massacre, a tale of pride, power, and the pursuit of justice that still echoes across the hills of Virginia today.
