Welcome to The Old ’76 House, a historic gem nestled in the heart of Tappan, New York. This Colonial-era tavern has been serving patrons since its construction in 1754 by Casparus Mabie, a local merchant and tavern-keeper. Though local legends suggest its origins date back to 1668, historical records confirm that it was established just a few decades before the American Revolution.
During the Revolutionary War, The Old ’76 House played a significant role in the local community. It became a meeting place for local patriots and, most notably, served as the prison for Major John André, a British spy entangled in the infamous treason of Benedict Arnold. André’s capture and subsequent execution were pivotal moments in the war, and his trial took place nearby at the Tappan Reformed Church.
While some stories suggest that George Washington himself dined here, historical evidence shows that his headquarters were set up at the nearby DeWint House, where he negotiated the British evacuation of New York City with General Sir Guy Carleton. Nonetheless, The Old ’76 House remains a symbol of the era, offering a glimpse into the past with its preserved architecture and ambience.
Over the years, The Old ’76 House has evolved from a simple tavern to a beloved restaurant and live music venue, still capturing the spirit of its Revolutionary roots. The Nordens, who purchased the establishment in 1987, undertook a meticulous restoration to maintain its historical charm, using period materials to restore the structure.
Today, whether you’re enjoying a hearty traditional American meal or tapping your foot to live music on a weekend, you’re part of a living history that stretches back over 250 years. As you explore this storied location, imagine the echoes of the past reverberating through its walls, telling tales of espionage, revolution, and resilience.
